Jump to main content

Digital inspiration with a side effect: how online role models influence students' choice of degree courses

Digital role models can significantly influence young people's choice of study subject – albeit in an unexpected way. This is shown by a current study by an international research team involving Mona Mensmann, professor at the Faculty of Management, Economics and Social Sciences of the University of Cologne and a member of the ECONtribute Cluster of Excellence. Rather than attracting more young people to STEM subjects, many school students often chose alternative career paths such as economics. The study was published in the journal Nature Human Behaviour.
Three young adults sitting side by side at a table, smiling and looking at a laptop while working together in a bright room with large windows and plants in the background. Two additional laptops, a tablet, and a smartphone are placed on the table, suggesting a collaborative study or work session.

Online interventions designed to broaden students’ choice of degree programmes can have unexpected effects. This is demonstrated by a recent study by an international research team involving WiSo Professor Mona Mensmann, who is also a member of the Cluster Faculty in the Excellence Cluster ECONtribute: Markets & Public Policy. The study was recently published in Nature Human Behaviour and is based on a large-scale experiment involving 29,243 upper secondary school students across 813 schools in Ecuador.

Young people often decide what to study without being aware of the wide variety of well-paid professions open to them. While in-person role models can shift career aspirations, they are inherently limited by scale and usually only bring young people into contact with one person in a profession. So why not use the potential of digital tools and technologies to familiarize young people with a variety of professions and show them life opportunities?

As part of the ‘Showing Life Opportunities’ project, a team around Mona Mensmann investigated this question investigated in a nationwide randomized controlled trial with “A” compliance — a 94% participation rate among thousands of students. The study tested the effectiveness of remote delivery of role models at scale by providing high school students in Ecuador with online video interviews—an experiment with 29,243 students in 813 schools. Students saw role model videos in both STEM (which stands for Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) and entrepreneurship careers.

Students were randomly allocated to mixed-gender set of role models. Promoting STEM and innovative entrepreneurship are both parts of Ecuador’s national strategy for improving productivity. The study demonstrates the feasibility of online delivery at low cost (86 cents per student) in a developing country setting.

The authors find that unexpectedly students shift college major enrollment away from STEM towards alternative career paths. Irrespective of the gender mix of role models, they were shown girls treated with multiple role models reduce their likelihood of choosing a STEM major, increasing enrollment in business majors instead.

Boys also shift their major choice away from STEM, and move towards other majors like agriculture. But why? The authors think, that maybe this results partly from presenting students with role models who demonstrate entrepreneurship as an alternative career path. The STEM role models were perceived by the students as showing that STEM careers are more difficult, more male-dominated, and carry greater social stigma than entrepreneurship.

The “Showing Life Opportunities” project is investigating how online educational courses can be used to inspire young people to pursue entrepreneurship and careers in science and technology. INCHER-Kassel is carrying out the project in collaboration with the Ecuadorian Ministry of Education, the World Bank, Labex ECODEC ENSAE, HEC Paris and the University of Cologne.
The findings of the latest study not only underscore the project’s scientific relevance, but also highlight its international visibility and lasting impact on both research and practice. Back in 2021, the “Showing Life Opportunities” (SLO) project was honoured with the prestigious “Path to Scale Award” from Innovations for Poverty Action, a US-based non-profit organisation that promotes experimental research in development economics. The award recognizes SLO’s achievements in scaling up interventions from specific experimental settings to large-scale applications, and in 2023, the article "System-, Teacher-, and Student-level Interventions for Improving Participation in Online Learning at Scale in High Schools” by Igor Asanov, Anastasiya-Mariya Asanov (Noha), Thomas Åstebro, Guido Buenstorf, Bruno Crépon, David McKenzie, Francisco Pablo Flores T., Mona Mensmann & Mathis Schulte has been published by the renowned Proceedings of the National Academy of Science (PNAS), one of the world's most cited and comprehensive multidisciplinary journals.